When to Use Glycerin vs. Alcohol for Herbal Extracts

The choice between glycerin and alcohol as a menstruum (solvent) depends on the herb, intended use, extraction needs, and who will be using it. Below is a comparison to help determine when to use each.

---

1. When to Use Alcohol (Ethanol) for Herbal Extracts (Tinctures)

✅ Best for: Strong, long-lasting medicinal extracts
✅ Best solvent for: Alkaloids, resins, volatile oils, and tannins
✅ Shelf life: 5+ years

Use Alcohol When:

• You need a highly potent extract (e.g., adaptogens, nervines, immune boosters).
• Extracting tough plant parts (roots, barks, resins, mushrooms).
• Extracting alkaloids, essential oils, and resins (e.g., echinacea, valerian, goldenseal, ashwagandha).
• Long shelf life is important (tinctures last 5+ years).
• You want rapid absorption into the bloodstream.

Common Herbs for Alcohol Tinctures:

Herb	Why Alcohol?
Echinacea	Strong immune-boosting alkaloids
Valerian Root	Potent sedative compounds
Ashwagandha	Adaptogenic properties require strong extraction
Goldenseal	Contains bitter alkaloids that dissolve best in alcohol
Reishi Mushroom	Tough, woody texture needs high-proof alcohol
Ginger Root	Extracts volatile oils and active compounds well

Tip: Use 40–50% alcohol for soft herbs (leaves, flowers) and 60–95% alcohol for roots, barks, and resins.

---

2. When to Use Glycerin for Herbal Extracts (Glycerites)

✅ Best for: Alcohol-free, sweet, child-friendly extracts
✅ Best solvent for: Mucilage, flavonoids, tannins, and water-soluble compounds
✅ Shelf life: 1–2 years

Use Glycerin When:

• The extract is for children, pets, or alcohol-sensitive individuals.
• You want a sweet and palatable tincture.
• Extracting mucilaginous (soothing) herbs.
• Making herbal skincare (glycerin is moisturizing).
• Preserving herbs with a mild antibacterial effect but no alcohol.
• The extract will be used short-term (1–2 years shelf life).

Common Herbs for Glycerin Extracts:

Herb	Why Glycerin?
Marshmallow Root	High in mucilage (soothing for digestion and throat)
Chamomile	Gentle for children and sleep support
Lemon Balm	Mild nervine, best for kids and stress relief
Licorice Root	Soothing for coughs and adrenal support
Nettle	Mineral-rich, good for nourishing extracts
Elderberry	Sweet glycerite for immune support

Tip: Use 60% glycerin + 40% distilled water for proper preservation and extraction.

---

3. When to Use a Combination of Alcohol & Glycerin

✅ Best for: Herbs that extract well in both solvents and need a balanced taste & potency
✅ Example Ratio: 50% alcohol + 50% glycerin

Use Alcohol + Glycerin When:

• You want a longer shelf life but better taste than a full alcohol tincture.
• The herb contains both alcohol-soluble and water-soluble compounds.
• The extract is for mild medicinal purposes but needs some alcohol for potency.
• The herbal extract is for children, but alcohol is needed for preservation.

Herbs That Work Well with a Mix of Alcohol & Glycerin:

• Elderberry (immune support)
• Lemon balm (nervine, antiviral)
• Ginger (digestive aid)
• Licorice root (soothing, anti-inflammatory)
• Echinacea (immune-boosting, alcohol helps extract alkaloids)

Tip: If using alcohol and glycerin together, add alcohol first, then glycerin after maceration.

---

Final Comparison Chart

Feature	Alcohol Tinctures	Glycerin Tinctures (Glycerites)
Best For	Strong medicinal extracts	Alcohol-free alternatives
Soluble Compounds	Alkaloids, resins, essential oils	Mucilage, flavonoids, tannins
Tough Plant Parts	Yes (roots, barks, resins, mushrooms)	No (best for soft plants)
Shelf Life	5+ years	1–2 years
Taste	Bitter, strong	Sweet, mild
Best for Kids?	No	Yes
Absorption	Fast (alcohol absorbs quickly)	Slower (coats throat, digestive support)
Preservation	Best (antimicrobial, long-lasting)	Moderate (mild preservation)
Best Used In	Tinctures, extracts, medicinal tonics	Glycerites, skincare, syrups

---

Which One Should You Use?

✅ Use alcohol if you want a strong, long-lasting medicinal extract.
✅ Use glycerin if you want an alcohol-free, sweet, and kid-friendly extract.
✅ Use both if you want a balanced taste, mild alcohol preservation, and versatility.